Episode 412: Israel’s Political Future: A New Government, or More of the Same?

What does the future hold for Israel and how will its political divisions, regional security challenges and changing relationship with the United States shape the country in the years ahead?

In this episode of the International Risk Podcast, host Dominic Bowen speaks with Professor Dov Waxman about the major forces shaping Israel’s future, from the war in Gaza and the challenges of regional security to the changing dynamics of US-Israel relations.

In this episode:

  • Israel’s political future and the prospects for change after Netanyahu
  • Why military force alone cannot defeat Hamas
  • The future of Gaza and the need for alternative Palestinian governance
  • The changing bipartisan consensus on US support for Israel
  • Whether American military support could become more conditional
  • Generational shifts in Israeli politics and society
  • The implications for regional security and the wider international order

Episode Transcript:

Dominic Bowen
Israel’s election was meant to settle the country’s direction after three years of war, but… it’s actually produced deadlock that neither Benjamin Netanyahu or Gadi Eisenkot can easily break. So what does the result reveal about Israeli politics? What could it mean for regional security and Israel’s place in the wider geopolitical picture? And ultimately, what should businesses and governments in the region be considering when they’re looking at Israel and the broader Middle East?

Dominic Bowen
I’m Dominic Bowen, host of The International Risk Podcast, where we unpack some of the most important topics that really matter. And today we’re joined by Dov Waxman. He’s a professor and holder of the Presidential Chair in modern Jewish studies at UCLA, and he’s the author of four books on Israeli politics and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Dominic Bowen
Dov, Welcome to The International Risk Podcast.

Dov Waxman
Thank you for having me on the show.

Dominic Bowen
Whereabouts in the world did we find you today?

Dov Waxman
I am in Los Angeles, sunny Los Angeles.

Dominic Bowen
Sunny Los Angeles. Perfect. Well, I think most of our listeners in Europe will be quite sad right now. We’re really getting into the winter months. but very jealous for you.

Dov Waxman
Yes, it’s hard to imagine winter exists in other places when you live in Los Angeles.

Dominic Bowen
Well, you’ve positioned yourself well And I guess I’m wondering if Benjamin Netanyahu’s positioned himself well. I mean, his coalition’s lost its parliamentary majority and the former military chief, Gadi Eisenkot, he’s emerging as the likely successor. But the outcome as of today, at the time we’re recording, remains very unclear. Now coalition negotiations are underway.

Dominic Bowen
There’s been allegations of intellectual fraud. And, of course, the political divisions have only deepened. And there’s some really big questions about Israel’s future and about its politics. Can you explain the most important points? What do we need to understand about what’s happening now in early November in Israel?

Dov Waxman
Well, I think, first of all, that the election result from last week really showed that a majority of Israelis have repudiated Netanyahu and his government. I mean, it went down from 68 seats in the last in parliament to just 53.

Dov Waxman
And in fact, as of today, it looks like even less than that. So first of all, I think it’s very important to understand that contrary to how Netanyahu has been trying to spin this as some kind of a victory, this was really a significant defeat.

Dov Waxman
for Netanyahu and for his Likud party and for the government. And it signals that the majority of Israeli voters want to change. Whether they’ll get a change is a different question. But I think it does demonstrate the degree to which the government that’s been in power in Israel for the past four years has become deeply unpopular among many Israelis.

Dominic Bowen
And I wonder, to obviously the US has just gone through its midterm elections and there’s there’s a lot of dialogue going on right now. Did the Democrats win? Or did Trump just lose the midterm elections and even some political analysts are talking about, or actually did Iran just help the Republicans lose the midterm elections? And I guess a similar question when looking at Israeli politics is.

Dominic Bowen
Is there actually a genuine political realignment in Israel? Or is it simply just a rejection of Netanyahu’s leadership and the corruption that comes with it?

Dov Waxman
Well, On the one hand, the basic voting patterns in this most recent election haven’t really shifted. And it’s quite remarkable if you think about you know everything that’s happened in Israel and in the region over the last few years.

Dov Waxman
I mean, even before October the 7th and the war in Gaza, you had you know massive street protests on a weekly basis, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of Israelis turning out to oppose.

Dominic Bowen
Yep.

Dov Waxman
the so-called judicial reform that the Netanyahu government tried to introduce to limit or restrict the power and independence of the Israeli judiciary. Then, of course, you had the October 7th attack, the worst domestic terrorist attack in Israel’s history, the deadliest day in Israel’s history, the worst security failure.

Dov Waxman
Following that, the longest war between Israel and the Palestinians, a war in which the Gaza Strip’s been devastated. Israel has been accused of committing crimes against humanity and even genocide. Wars with Iran, wars in Lebanon, and moving into Syria as well. So given all of that, you might have thought that there would be some sort of major political realignment, that Israeli voters would have really shifted in response to those. developments.

Dov Waxman
But actually, the… basic kind of political map in israel

Dov Waxman
Barely shifted at all. I mean, essentially, for many, for a number of years now, Israeli politics has basically revolved around the question of Netanyahu’s leadership. There’s been, each election has really been a referendum on this lead on his leadership. That was true in the most recent election as well. It didn’t really… focus on Israel’s policies or on the changes in the region. It was really, again, focusing particularly on Netanyahu. And once again, you know, the Israeli Jewish public was really divided into two blocks, you know, the anti-Netanyahu, the pro-Netanyahu blocks. that really That electoral map hasn’t really shifted. The only significant and really noteworthy development on election day was the massive turnout by Arab voters, Arab citizens of Israel, who voted in impressive unprecedented numbers. And it was there, this huge increase in turnout by Arab voters, which led to the historic performance of Arab parties in this election, receiving 19 seats. That could… This newfound power that Arab parties have, that is a record number of seats for Arab parties to hold in the parliament, that could lead to a…

Dov Waxman
major and dramatic realignment in Israeli politics if the anti-Netanyahu opposition bloc were willing to form a minority government that either they included those Arab majority parties or depended upon their parliamentary support. I think that’s unlikely. And so in that respect…

Dov Waxman
I don’t think there’s going to be a major realignment. But as even of today, we’re seeing the big the possibility for another one, which is one of the things that’s really helped Netanyahu and the right remain in power for so long has been the alliance.

Dov Waxman
that Netanyahu and the Likud party formed with the ultra-Orthodox parties, these ultra-Orthodox Jewish parties that have very that really are just trying to represent the interests of their kind of a segment of Israeli voters, the ultra-Orthodox, and particularly important to them is the issue of the military draft and their exemption from that. As of this morning… the one of those parties which has long been kind of loyal coalition partners for netanyahu has not hasn’t endorsed him to be the next prime minister and is indicating that it might support a government led by Gadi Eisenkot.

Dov Waxman
If that… happens, that would that could end this long-time kind of alliance between the secular right and the religious right, and that could potentially reshape Israeli politics. So I think it’s too soon to say that there was a realignment, but it is a possibility for one as a result of these election results.

Dominic Bowen
You’ve raised a lot of really interesting points there. So let’s dive into one of them that you’ve written a lot about, and that’s the Israel’s Jewish and Palestinian citizens and how they live side by side. And I’m wondering about the health. of israelis democracy I mean, one of the most striking developments that really sat with me is the electoral success of the Arab parties.

Dominic Bowen
Now the Arab parties now hold 19 seats and from what I see just from a math point of view is that they could determine who actually governs Israel. But. Before we dive into that, I’d be keen to know. you know Does…

Dominic Bowen
Israel’s internal political divisions. increasingly become a national security vulnerability if we’re seeing Arab parties control the balance of power in Israel? Or is that is that just not an issue, not something we need to consider?

Dov Waxman
Well, no, actually, I mean, one of the reasons behind Hamas’s decision to launch the attack on October the 7th. was their belief that Israel’s internal divisions were preoccupying Israelis and had weakened the country. You know, those months, as I mentioned, of major protests, of domestic protests against the judicial reform in Israel, and even the refusal by some Israelis to serve, to perform military service because of their opposition to the judicial reform. that you know that domestic upheaval

Dov Waxman
did contribute to, did inform Yahya Sinwa’s decision to launch the attack on October the 7th. So there’s always been a connection between Israel’s domestic politics and particularly the kind of internal divisions and its external relations and what happens between Israelis and Palestinians. And so, yes, I think if in going forward…

Dov Waxman
the you know Israeli government is really hamstrung and that we don’t have a government, there may well be more elections if a government isn’t formed. That’s, I think, a very distinct possibility.

Dov Waxman
if that if that if that’s the case It will be many more months before a government is formed. And that certainly, from the point of view of Israel’s adversaries in the region and Israel’s relations with other countries in the region, is going to is going to be affected by the lack of a stable government. Israel, I think, could be entering a renewed period of domestic political instability.

Dov Waxman
Precisely because the election results did not result in a decisive majority for the anti-Netanyahu bloc. without relying upon Arab party support. And so, yeah, that is certainly something that Israel’s adversaries will be paying a lot of attention to, as they’ve always done in the past.

Dominic Bowen
And you spoke about Gaza, or you spoke about Hamas. I’m wondering how important the war in Gaza was to this election. I mean, Eisenkot, he’s a security hawk. His positions on Palestinians, his position on regional security. from what I see, very close to Netanyahu’s, perhaps closer than many observers might actually expect. So both Netanyahu and Eisenkot.

Dominic Bowen
pitched any Hamas rule. But. From what I see of the polling, it suggests that much like America, much like Europe, the cost of living. was one of the main issues, but also the judicial reforms that you’ve referred to a few times. These were just as important to many of the voters. So from what you’re seeing in the wash up.

Dominic Bowen
Did Israelis vote on the war or did they vote on everything else that was around it?

Dov Waxman
Well, certainly the war in Gaza was a factor, not because Israelis, or at least Jewish Israelis, opposed the war or wanted is want Israel to pursue very different policies vis-a-vis the Gaza Strip or vis-a-vis Hamas. As you mentioned, Eisenkot didn’t say much about what he would do differently with regards to Gaza. I think there are some significant differences, but I don’t think that was what influenced the vote. what did influence them, to at least for many more secular Israelis, was a couple of factors. First of all, the government’s refusal to establish a national commission a state commission of inquiry into the events of October the 7th. So that was something that obviously relates to the war in Gaza. And there’s a strong demand by many Israelis to have an official inquiry into the failure to prevent.

Dov Waxman
October the 7th. The other factor, I think, in the way that the war itself impacted the election was the belief among opponents of the government that Netanyahu and his far-right coalition parties

Dov Waxman
prolonged the war for political reasons, that they could have ended the war sooner and brought the hostages home earlier. But they didn’t do that because of the need, essentially, for coalition unity, because the far-right parties would have likely bolted, left the government, had Netanyahu agreed to a ceasefire earlier. That was, in fact, the reason why Gadi Eisenkot…

Dov Waxman
resigned from the war cabinet that he was a it was a member of during the early months of the war in Gaza. so The Warren guys have certainly cast a long shadow over this election, but…

Dov Waxman
But the election wasn’t really about… policies toward Gaza. or for that matter, policies towards the West Bank or the Palestinians or the wider region. and But I do think, although there aren’t huge differences between Eisenkot and Netanyahu, you know, the devil is in the details, as they say. And I think, for example, although both…

Dov Waxman
are committed to destroying Hamas. And, you know, the way they’re going to try and do that would differ. In the in In Eisenkot’s case, I think he would be more willing to work with the Board of Peace if that Board of Peace survives after the midterm elections. or That’s another matter. But I think…

Dov Waxman
you know,

Dov Waxman
Netanyahu kind of quickly ruled out essentially working with the Board of Peace. He’s refused to allow the technocratic government, the Palestinian technocratic government, into Gaza. There’s been restrictions on humanitarian aid entering Gaza or for the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip. I think Eisenkot would be more willing to work with the Board of Peace. And while I think he’d be unlikely to withdraw Israeli troops from the Gaza Strip before Hamas’s disarmament,

Dov Waxman
you know, I think they would be more willing to allow for the regular. delivery of humanitarian aid and for the reconstruction of Gaza to get underway and for that technocratic government in that to enter Gaza. So, you know, from the perspective of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, these differences can matter. They won’t bring about… the end of Israeli of israeli troops in the Gaza Strip anytime soon, but they can make a real difference to the lives of Palestinians in that the Gaza Strip who desperately need, you know, at the very least, more humanitarian aid to enter the Strip and reconstruction to begin there.

Dominic Bowen
I mean, this is a political conversation, but it’s something that continues to come up and you’ve referred to it a few times. I wonder if you can help us understand a little bit. Israel is an extremely powerful and extremely competent military with…

Dominic Bowen
you know, vast intelligence apparatus both human signal intelligence and of course it’s drone and aircraft capability is you know phenomenal How is it? after several years of conflict and after almost flattening the entire Gaza Strip, that Hamas still has weapons.

Dominic Bowen
what’s What’s going on there? Can you help us understand the situation?

Dov Waxman
Well, I mean, it’s very difficult, I think, for any military, even one as powerful as Israel, to completely prevent the rearmament of militant groups. I mean, for one thing now, Hamas is rearming. Part of what’s enabling Hamas to rearm is the underground tunnels that you know, smuggling tunnels from Sinai, as well as apparently drones that are also bringing in supplies into the Gaza Strip. Hamas has largely lost.

Dov Waxman
its indigenous arms production capability, which it had before, where it was actually producing its own rockets and even being able to develop guided rockets into Israel. So it has lost largely that, but it is now able to just kind of smuggle arms back into the Gaza Strip. But I think, you know, there’s a couple of explanations for why.

Dov Waxman
Israel has kind of you know, failed really to defeat or destroy Hamas. And I mean, part of it was its military strategy in the first place, unlike fighting, say, unlike, say, what the Americans and the British did in Iraq.

Dov Waxman
where its strategy of counterinsurgency warfare was to you know clear an area and then to put up a some sort of governance there which would then to ensure that militants couldn’t return 16:41.84
Dov Waxman
Israel didn’t do that. Essentially, Israel, the IDF kind of went into areas, you know, defeated Hamas in those areas and then moved on to other parts of the Gaza Strip and allowed Hamas then to reconstitute itself in areas from which… it had previously been defeated but more broadly, ultimately, I think it comes down to the fact that Israel’s approach in the Gaza Strip. has been to prevent the establishment of an alternative form of Palestinian governance. The only way ultimately that you can really remove Hamas is by allowing for the formation of an alternative governance in the Gaza Strip. The Israeli government, the Netanyahu government, particularly because of its far reliance on the far right, did not allow… The Palestinian Authority you know blocked the Biden administration’s attempt to bring the Palestinian Authority into the Gaza Strip. And as I’ve mentioned, it is it has also been preventing the entry of a technocratic government that’s not aligned with the Palestinian Authority. What that has essentially meant is that while the IDF currently controls between, say, 65 to 70 percent of the Gaza Strip.

Dov Waxman
In the areas that it doesn’t occupy and control, Hamas has basically the remain still the ruling power in those areas. It’s still able to rule in those areas. It’s still able to generate funds as a result of its rule in those areas and terrorize.

Dov Waxman
the population under its control. And so ultimately, the only way to really dislodge Hamas would have been, I think, to have allowed for an alternative government to a regime to emerge there. The other factor, of course, is ultimately, in terms of Hamas’s disarmament.

Dov Waxman
you know it ultimately is very difficult to do especially when we’re talking about small arms it’s one thing i think to i think as israel hat was able to do was to destroy its kind of locket capabilities and heavy weaponry but small arms which is what it uses to terrorize its own population it’s very difficult to eliminate that ultimately you know as you know i’m british and so i kind of think about the experience of the ira for example in northern ireland and what we what we saw there is that the ultimate the only way to ultimately disarm those paramilitary groups in northern ireland was through a peace process that entailed their gradual

Dov Waxman
decommissioning of weapons, gradually handing over their weapons in exchange for the gradual withdrawal of British forces.

Dov Waxman
from northern ireland and the establishment of a power sharing in other words there has to be a political or diplomatic solution you’re not going to be able just through the use of military force alone to forcibly disarm a militant, or as you say, you’re not going to be able to do that without a massive cost to civilians in Gaza. I mean, some would argue that has happened. But in most cases, it’s very hard to prevent militant groups from rearming.

Dominic Bowen
And You know, if we look a little bit further, the strategic environments around Israel has changed dramatically over the last three years. I mean, Iran and its regional partners have suffered significant military setbacks, but they’re still operational, whether it’s Hezbollah in Lebanon, whether it’s the Houthis in Yemen, and we’ve spoken about Hamas in Palestine.

Dominic Bowen
And all of these confrontations remain. and resolved. In fact, some of them seem even stronger. than ever I mean, the Houthis have been causing significant damage in Saudi Arabia over the last month.

Dominic Bowen
And the issues in Gaza, in the West Bank, in Lebanon, in Syria continue to present. issues that Israel needs to consider. So I wonder if Eisenkot becomes prime minister.

Dominic Bowen
Would you expect a more restrained? approach to regional security. Or… yeah know is there Is there a new political spectrum in Israel that’s going to stay, that is simply more assertive, it’s more aggressive than most international observers would like?

Dominic Bowen
What would you expect from Eisenkot moving forward?

Dov Waxman
Yes, well, I think it’s important to… for listeners for your listeners to understand that the shift in Israel’s national security strategy that’s taken place over the last few years since october the 7th is one that is widely agreed upon by many Jewish Israelis and by many Israeli political parties, including Eisenkot. And basically, at the heart of that strategic shift is a move away from relying upon…

Dov Waxman
military deterrence, the idea that you know Israel could rely upon early warning to prevent, to warn it of any potential attack, and the using its military might to deter attack, toward whats what’s what we might call forward defense, which basically means deploying the Israeli military in… enemy territory so as to push threats away from Israel’s borders and to actually hold and occupy territory. And we’ve seen this most obviously, of course, in the Gaza Strip, where, as I mentioned, Israel, the IDF… continues to control between 65, 70 % of the territory and is unlikely to withdraw from the Gaza Strip anytime soon. It’s really, you know, establishing bases there, establishing the infrastructure on the ground in the Gaza for potentially a long-term occupation. We’re also seeing that same strategy, though, in Lebanon.

Dov Waxman
where having largely you know cleared out or depopulated many Shia-majority villages in southern Lebanon, the IDF is also looks likely to remain in southern Lebanon for some time, and also in southern Syria as well. And so this is really, I think, this really reflects a strategy of holding… occupying territory, pushing threats away from civilian communities that are located near Israel’s borders so they are not… are at risk of kind of short-range rockets or the kind of you know cross-border raid

Dov Waxman
that was so devastating on october the 7th and this has real repercussions then for israel’s regional relations because by kind of adopting this much more you know assertive and militaristic approach to its security one that involves occupying territory rather than just relying on deterrence that is going to strain certainly israel’s

Dov Waxman
relations with the Lebanese government and the Syrian government, which obviously don’t want Israeli troops occupying parts of their territory. But also it’s going to strain its relations with other Arab states in the region who you know who are worried about this that kind of much more assertive Israeli… national security strategy i don’t think eisenkot is going to depart from that because that is

Dov Waxman
There is a broad consensus. among at least among Jewish Israelis, that Israel can no longer rely purely upon deterrence and early warning and kind of defensive fortifications like the barrier between the Gaza Strip and Israel or the barrier that it built between the on the long the Lebanese border. That approach which dominated Israel’s kind of national security.

Dov Waxman
strategy

Dov Waxman
for over a decade, really. That approach, I think, is seen to have failed. October the 7th is widely seen to have demonstrated that, you know, Early warning isn’t always reliable. Israel had all of that sophisticated intelligence apparatus. It had all of the signals, if you like, but it wasn’t able to put it together in time to prevent the attack. And of course, its deterrence failed. Hamas wasn’t deterred. Hezbollah similarly wasn’t deterred. And so the view, I think, the conclusion that many Jewish Israelis and their political parties have drawn from

Dov Waxman
October the 7th is that in fact the IDF needs to be kind of more willing to actually remain and in an occupied territory and hold territory as a kind of forward defense in order to push away from Israel’s borders militant groups who could pose a threat to Israeli civilians.

Dominic Bowen
Yeah, I’d love to ask you about that because that occupying territory, there’s a difference between… what you might do for security and what you might do that complies with the law. I mean, Israel says it’s occupying parts of southern Syria to prevent hostile armed groups from threatening Israeli territories.

Dominic Bowen
However, its military operations are clearly serving a much broader set of objectives. They’re controlling territory that overlooks the Golan Heights. They’re restricting Syria’s military capabilities.

Dov Waxman
Right.

Dominic Bowen
And as soon as the Syrian authorities, an authority or a new government that is largely respected internationally, Israel just simply destroys those military capabilities. They’re clearly trying to limit Turkish influence in the area. and they’re maintaining significant leverage over Syria’s new government. Now. this military presence in Southern Syria. I think is difficult to justify legally.

Dominic Bowen
particularly given its stated intention to maintain military positions indefinitely to occupy them. Now, the United Nations has documented israeli’s military activities involving civilian detentions involving restrictions of movement involving searches of homes and damaged agricultural lands In fact, in September, the UN said that some of the Israeli actions in Syria likely constitute war crimes.

Dominic Bowen
is Syria. And I think many people in Syria are just desperate for peace after over a decade of civil war. And it’s the moment, literally within days of the civil war ending, Israel started occupying territory, started arresting Syrian citizens. and destroying infrastructure.

Dominic Bowen
Is there likely to be… any easing of the conflict and the land grab and the occupation in neighboring countries. under a new government or is this going to be the status quo for the foreseeable future.

Dov Waxman
Well, I think I would. distinguish between Syria and Lebanon in this respect. I think when it comes to Syria, which the Trump administration do, you know, have normalized relations with Syria, have ended you sanctions on so on the regime, they want the new regime in Syria to succeed, I think.

Dominic Bowen
Yep.

Dov Waxman
And they want to support that. And they recognize, I think, that Israel’s prolonged Israeli military occupation of parts of southern Syria would actually not serve US interests in with regards to Syria.

Dov Waxman
So I would expect there to be some…

Dov Waxman
more pressure from the Trump administration potentially on the Israeli government, if it was an Eisenkot-led government, to reduce and maybe ultimately to remove Israeli forces from Syria. Because there isn’t a strong demand among the Israeli public for Israel to remain in Syria. In fact, there is some debate and there has been some domestic debate in Israel over…

Dov Waxman
the actions, as you mentioned, actions that the is that Israel has taken in Syria, because basically some of the critics have argued, look, you have a new government in Syria that is talking about having an agreement with Israel, that is, you know, apparently more open to even establishing a peace agreement with Israel. Why squander that opportunity?

Dov Waxman

Dominic Bowen
Mm hmm.

Dov Waxman
a potentially historic opportunity to, you know, to form a, to establish a relationship with, a peaceful relationship with Syria by engaging in those kinds of policies and actions which don’t necessarily really bring Israel long-term security.

Dov Waxman
So I think there might be movement on when it comes to Syria because of the, especially if the Trump administration decide to, you know, put some pressure on.

Dominic Bowen
Yep.

Dov Waxman
Lebanon is in a different matter because That’s a long-standing issue. You have a large number but relatively large number of Israelis who lived near southern Lebanon, near the border with Lebanon. And the fear of Hezbollah…

Dov Waxman
and the fear and the And the lack of confidence that Israel has in the Lebanese government and the Lebanese army to take over those areas that Hezbollah has left, I think it’s going to be harder domestically.

Dov Waxman
for an eisenkot led government for example to really change israel’s policies in lebanon now That doesn’t mean to say… it will continue to you know, displace tens of thousands of Lebanese civilians as has happened over the last few months. But I think it would be harder for that for Eisenkot-led government to withdraw Israeli troops from Lebanon.

Dov Waxman
than it would be from Syria. but for domestic reasons and while i do think the trump administration would also probably like the Israelis to, you know, withdrawal from southern Lebanon as well.

Dov Waxman
that might be a harder ask than Syria.

Dov Waxman
because i say there is the at least the potential with Syria to get this agreement between the Syrian government and Israel. In the in the case of Lebanon, that’s less likely because of Lebanon’s domestic politics. So, yeah, I wouldn’t expect major changes insofar as I think it would be unrealistic to expect an Eisenkot-led government to completely withdraw Israeli troops from…

Dov Waxman
Gaza, certainly not the West Bank. from Syria and they won’t be. total withdrawal but maybe syria which is the more which where there’s less of a consensus that Israel needs to be, that the IDF needs to be in Syria, that would be where I would maybe expect there to be potential for a reduction and a withdrawal even of Israeli forces.

Dominic Bowen
Yeah. Yeah, I think that would be welcomed by many different actors. and looking at how Eisenkot might form. a foreign government. And looking at how Isengard might form a government and what his foreign policy might be, I’m wondering… if you’d expect there to be any changes in Israel’s relationship towards Washington and maybe even Europe, and if there’s new opportunities to rebuild diplomatic influence between Europe and Israel. and

Dominic Bowen
Israel’s relationship with the US. How would you expect the Eisenkot government to treat those issues?

Dov Waxman
Well, I think certainly the hope… among many Israelis is that, you know, a changing government in Israel, removing Netanyahu from power, would lead to an improvement in U. S.-Israel relations, or particularly in Israel’s standing among Americans, and would help, they hope.

Dov Waxman
to repair relations between Israel and the Democratic Party, which is, of course, now in control of Congress. 32:24.17
Dov Waxman
And so I think you’d kind of see a charm offensive, if you like, an attempt to you know to highlight this change of government in Israel, that Netanyahu’s out of the picture, and the hope that this will really improve U. S.-Israel relations and reduce some of the opposition and criticism of Israel in D. C.

Dov Waxman
I think that’s unrealistic. I think actually, you know, just having a different leader while, you know, there may be a brief honeymoon period at the end of the day, I think. you know the shift that has taken place among them in terms of American public opinion. Vis-a-vis Israel, which is really…

Dov Waxman
far reaching and quite profound. I think that’s such that I don’t think Israelis have fully appreciated the significance of this shift. I think they see it largely as Netanyahu’s fault and that, you know, if you could get rid of Netanyahu, certainly.

Dov Waxman
widely unpopular among Americans is even toxic among Democrats. But I don’t think that… alone, removing Netanyahu, having a new face as an Israeli leader. would be sufficient to restore Israel’s standing. What’s needed is rather a much broader change of Israeli policies, particularly toward the Palestinians. and i think that’s unlikely so

Dov Waxman
I think, yes, the there will be…

Dov Waxman
I think we can expect some improvement. I mean, certainly if Netanyahu were to remain and as Israel’s leader, you know israel’s you’d see a continued deterioration. really of israel standing and you know real tension between a democratically controlled Congress and the Israeli government. But even with a different government in office in Jerusalem, i… don’t think there’s going to be a dramatic shift without a change in Israel’s policies. And that’s even more the case when it comes to Europe.

Dov Waxman
I mean, what European, Western European countries, EU, most of the countries in the, most of the states in the EU want to see is real changes in Israel’s policies. They’ve already started, we’ve already seen now the beginning of sanctions and sanctions on Israeli settlements.

Dov Waxman
And I think absent major changes, I mean dramatic changes, I think, you know, there’s going to be continued efforts to hold Israel accountable for violations of international law and to impose…

Dov Waxman
and to and to impose costs. on the Israeli government for its policies. so There’s a kind of growing… Now, that might not those you know that might not happen right away. They might give…

Dov Waxman
the if there is a new government, an Eisenkot-led government, they might, you know, I think that the European governments would probably be wise to… wait and see for a little while to see if it’s going to introduce some significant changes. But I think the nature of any government that comes to being the is going to make it very difficult for it to make major dramatic changes because of coalition stability and coalition unity. so

Dov Waxman
i think it’s quite likely then that european governments european leaders will eventually… decide well you know we’ve given it some time we’ve waited to see if there’s going to be a real change of direction in israel’s policies It hasn’t happened. And therefore, we’re going to continue to apply more pressure, more punitive measures.

Dov Waxman
And I think eventually that will happen in the United States as well. That will take more time. and But really, you know, what’s going to be necessary to reset? Israel’s relations with.

Dov Waxman
Europe and the United States is a reset in Israel’s policies. not just a change in its leaders.

Dominic Bowen
Yeah, and I think, of course, Israel’s

Dominic Bowen
intent towards. some of its allies is one thing but some of how the allies are interpreting and reviewing Israel, I think is worth unpacking and the United States remains. and is clearly israel’s most important partner but the relationship is becoming really contested. And we saw US Vice President J. D. Vance, he’s made some of his strongest criticisms yet of America’s relationship with Israel. And the day after the midterms, he suggested that us the US s support for Israel and the war against Iran contributed to the Republican defeat in the midterm elections. And we’re seeing it across the political spectrum and across all levels of seniority that support for Israel has become much more divisive within American politics. especially

Dominic Bowen
but not only, but especially amongst younger voters and parts of the Democratic Party. Now you’ve studied the relationship between American Jewish communities and Israel extensively.

Dominic Bowen
Is the traditional bipartisan consensus support that Israel has had enjoyed for decades. Is this something that might be transferring and transforming? Could we reach a point where US military assistance, its diplomatic protection, and these strategic partnerships start to become more conditional on changing Israel policies? regardless of who occupies the White House? What are you expecting there?

Dov Waxman
Yes, I think, well… We’ve seen… you know, first of all, among democratic voters, and now… we’re getting to see among republicans we’ve seen a profound and a far-reaching shift take place among americans in terms of american public opinion here for a long time while europeans became

Dov Waxman
were very critical of Israel. Americans have always generally been very pro-Israel. That began to change around a decade ago among republican but among democratic voters. and much more recently just really since the beginning of the war in gaza and even particularly since the beginning of the war with Iran, among Republicans.

Dov Waxman
But that didn’t yet lead to that change among in American public opinion hasn’t yet manifested into a change of in terms of American policies.

Dov Waxman
I think we will begin to see the first changes in policy terms begin under a new democratic controlled Congress for the next two years. But I think particularly even more so if the Democrats retake the White House in 2028, then you will see really potentially really big shifts. I think certainly the era.

Dov Waxman
of the kind of bipartisan pro-israel consensus where democratic policy makers and Republican policymakers both strongly supported, uncritically supported the US alliance with Israel, and really were willing to provide you know aid to Israel, military aid, military assistance, and also diplomatic protection.

Dov Waxman
unconditionally basically i mean you know we saw this and this was the this was bipartisan The Biden administration obviously did this during the war in Gaza. The Trump administration has done it as well. Even the a but Obama administration, despite the you know animosity and tension between…

Dov Waxman
President Obama and Netanyahu personally. Let’s not forget it was the Obama administration that signed that Memorandum of Understanding, this 10-year aid.

Dov Waxman
agreement that provided a 38 billion dollars over a 10-year period 3.8 billion dollars a year so you know that just goes to underline that there was this broad and deep bipartisan consensus that is over and That era has come to an end. We are entering a new era of US-Israel relations, and one in which I think there will be much more demand among policymakers on both sides of the aisle.

Dov Waxman
for a more kind of conditional relationship in other words For Democrats, they will say, well, we will support Israel only if Israel, the Israeli government, you know.

Dov Waxman
does certain things or behaves in certain ways. In particular, they are going to… impose restrictions on how US-supplied weapons are used. There will be much more scrutiny of the use of those weapons, if even those weapons are going to still be sold to Israel. On the Republican side as well, though, I think the conditions are going to be different. The Democrats want to make sure that…

Dov Waxman
US support for Israel isn’t in violation of American values, if you like, and isn’t in violation of Palestinian human rights. That’s become a major issue, a domestic issue. for Democrats and for their voters. For Republicans, it’s different. It’s not so much about values and certainly not about, I think, Palestinian rights. It’s rather about American interests. And there is a concern, I think, and an argument among… republicans that israel has acted the israeli government and netanyahu in particular has acted in the ways that undermine american interests and for example this narrative that vance himself and others on the right have kind of promoted that you know, israel that the United States entered this war with Iran.

Dov Waxman
Because…

Dov Waxman
Netanyahu pushed them to do it. And this has come become so costly for the United States and ultimately cost the Republicans the midterms. So for Republicans as well, there’s going to be this much more kind of quid pro quo. We’re not going to just support whatever you want to do. We want to make sure that it serves America’s interests and what America gets out of it. On both sides, then, I think there’s going to be a different mentality when it comes to the U. S.-Israel relationship.

Dominic Bowen
And if we… dive a little bit, you know, looking at the changes in the American. election and some of their views towards Israel. But within Israel too, I think there’s some recent trends that are worth unpacking. And there’s some polling that indicates that approximately… three quarters of young Jewish Israeli voters. identify as rightwing or center right Now, I think importantly, this is not simply a reaction to the Hamas attacks of 7th of October.

Dominic Bowen
The academic research that’s been conducted suggests that this is a generational shift towards the political right that’s been developing for several decades. Can you tell us, Dov, why is that?

Dominic Bowen
and What does this mean for the future of Israeli politics after Netanyahu if the younger generation is… already. pushing to the right which is which is kind of counter-cultural to what we see with younger generations in most countries.

Dov Waxman
Yes, certainly. And certainly when compared to young people in the United States who have become much more critical of Israel, both young Republicans and young Democrats. For Israelis, there’s a couple of factors as to why young Jewish Israelis specifically have kind of, you know, become much more white wing than older Israelis.

Dov Waxman
Part of it has to do with just simple demographics. One of the fastest growing groups in Israeli society are ultra-Orthodox Jews, religious Jews, who tend to be more right-wing. And so as a share of the population, they’re more they skew younger. And so part of it is the…

Dov Waxman
growing numbers of young Israelis who are religious and ultra-Orthodox, but it’s also true among the more secular.

Dominic Bowen
Okay.

Dov Waxman
And for that, the reason for that is really because this generation of young Israelis have come of age, you know, they were born after the Oslo peace process. They were born after Oslo collapsed. they were They were born during the second intifada or afterwards. So they have only really known an Israel that has been fighting kind of successive wars against Hamas.

Dov Waxman
They’ve grown up under largely right wing governments during a period when many Israeli Jews really, you know, are across the political spectrum, except for a very small number still on the Israeli left, believe that there is you know no partner on the Palestinian side and really gave up.

Dov Waxman
hope for a two-state solution. So this generation has come of age during that period of time. And for many, they’ve never met a Palestinian, except maybe in when they’ve been serving in military service. You know, an older Israeli Jews may remember Palestinians who they knew.

Dov Waxman
Palestinians who they may have employed. But the this younger generation have… don’t have that first-hand experience. We see kind of really, you know, what can only be described as anti-Palestinian racism quite widespread among young Israeli Jews because they’ve kind of grown up in that in a culture that’s really vilified Palestinians and believe that Palestinians are…

Dov Waxman
It’s kind of destined to be Israel’s enemies. And so all of that has shaped their political attitudes. That’s been the environment in which they’ve been politically socialized. And so, yes, I think it does indicate that, you know, the kind of rightward trajectory.

Dov Waxman
of Israeli politics could be a lasting one, which is why this election and the ability to form a maybe a different government as a result of this election is so important.

Dov Waxman
because, you know… This election, because of the massive turnout, as I mentioned, of Arab voters, because of the number of his more secular Israelis.

Dov Waxman
who lived abroad who returned to vote in this election. This has opened the possibility. for a different government to pursue quite different policies particularly if that government was to rely upon the support of Arab parties that could really lead to a new chapter.

Dov Waxman
in not just Israeli-Palestinian relations, but Israel’s relations with the wider region. If that doesn’t happen… then I think, you know, there’s a good reason to expect that it will be harder over time.

Dov Waxman
for a you know, for non-white wing governments to emerge. precisely because of these demographic trends and because younger Israeli Jewish voters are more right-wing than older ones.

Dominic Bowen
And you’ve already written… four books and you lecture and you speak quite widely, but I understand youre you’re wrapping up a fifth book. So you clearly have a bit of ink left in your pen.

Dominic Bowen
What’s the topic? I understand it’s about antisemitism, but tell us, what’s the what else needs to be said about it? What’s the what’s the story? What’s the research? what compelled you to write this fifth book?

Dov Waxman
Well, I never thought I’d write a book about antisemitism. My scholarship is in the past really focused primarily on Israel, on Israeli society and politics and on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But one of the things I realized… through teaching and through giving talks and was that it’s become very difficult for people to talk about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict because of…

Dov Waxman
concerns about antisemitism, because and that the rise of antisemitism, which has happened in many parts of the world, including in the United States over the past decade. has become a subject that’s very difficult to discuss because of the ways in which it’s become entangled with the issue of Israel-Palestine. And so these two issues that… were once separate, for the issue of anti-Semitism, which, you know, until quite recently received little attention, and the issue of the Israel-Palestine and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, these two issues have in many places in the United States and in many countries in Europe, in Australia, in Canada, increasingly become entangled. And, you know, that’s given rise to very… intense and divisive debates about what is anti-Semitic vis-a-vis Israel, vis-a-vis Zionism, what kinds of actions or protests against Israel cross the line into anti-Semitism, what kind of speech. So the purpose of my book is really to provide readers with a guide to those very challenging and contentious questions, to actually try to look at what the

Dov Waxman
empirical data says about, for example, the relationship between anti-Israel attitudes or anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. When do the two meet? when do they where do they differ? to and also to kind of guide readers through these. very contentious debates about what is or isn’t anti-semitic vis-a-vis israel and zionism I don’t think the book alone can disentangle these two issues, but I do want to try to make it possible for us to discuss and identify anti-Semitism in a way that doesn’t become overly politicized by divisions around Israel-Palestine.

Dominic Bowen
Yeah, I think that’s incredibly important. there’s topics that are so important that have to be discussed, but in many cases, the sensitivity or the fear of certain labels just stops so many people from discussing them. So I’m really glad that you’ve written that and I look forward to reading that when it comes out in January. And just to wrap up, Dov, one question that we ask all guests on The International Risk Podcast is… When you look around the world, What are the international risks that concern you the most?

Dov Waxman
Well, Since I’m sitting here in the United States, and given the US, you know, what happens in the United States, as we all know, has… reverberates around the world.

Dov Waxman
I think, you know… Probably the biggest concern I have is looking at domestic political stability in the United States. I mean, i think I’m breathing a big sigh of relief that these midterm elections passed peacefully and that President Trump recognized the results. Let’s not forget that wasn’t a foregone conclusion given his refusal to recognize 2020 election and what happened on January the 6th. I don’t think we’re out of the woods yet though.

Dov Waxman
you know Now, obviously, there’s going to be a big focus on the up on the presidential election on 2028. and

Dov Waxman
You know, this country, the United States, remains deeply divided, notwithstanding the kind of blue tsunami that took place. We still have deep divisions among between Republicans and Democrats and the potential. for political violence and serious instability in the United States. And if that happens in the US…

Dov Waxman
you know that will reverberate, that will impact American policy all around the world. So just as you know the rise of Trump coming to power boosted…

Dov Waxman
authoritarian populism in many countries and elected autocrats and kind of led to this wave of, you know, of which Trump was a part of that white wing populism.

Dov Waxman
What happens in the United States will not only affect could not only affect… democracies in other parts of the world, but also, obviously, US foreign policy. So probably, you know, the that the future of democracy here in the United States, I think, is something that I think has obviously major…

Dov Waxman
importance not just for americans but for people around the world i mean we’ve seen how US policies affect their economic well-being.

Dov Waxman
of people around the world. And not just tariffs, but obviously the war with Iran. And so, you know, what President Trump’s going to do in the next few weeks vis-a-vis Iran is going to be something I’m obviously particularly paying attention to, because is he going to, you know, escalate or try and seek a kind of face-saving deal? And how else might Trump inform policy? Because now we know that…

Dov Waxman
His domestic agenda is basically dead in the water now. you know He’s likely to turn to foreign policy as the one area in which he can still really do things. And you know a wound a politically wounded leader.

Dov Waxman
who is hamstrung domestically. We have to, I think, be quite careful about what’s going to happen in US foreign policy over the next couple of years and what’s going to happen in American society and politics as the 2028 presidential election approaches.

Dominic Bowen
Yeah, I think they’re all very valid issues. So thanks very much for raising those, Dov. Thank you very much. for coming on The International Risk Podcast today.

Dov Waxman
Thank you. It’s been a pleasure

Dominic Bowen
Well, that was a great conversation with Dov Waxman. He’s a professor and holder of the Presidential Chair in Modern Jewish Studies at UCLA. and I really appreciated hearing his thoughts on Israel’s election, regional security, and what this all means for you.

Dominic Bowen
Today’s episode was produced and coordinated by Andrea Crafoord. I’m Dominic Bowen, your host. Thanks very much for listening to The International Risk Podcast. We’ll speak again in the next couple of days.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *